1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. How to prioritize tasks

How to prioritize tasks when everything feels urgent

Daily Planner Maker team7 min read

To prioritize tasks, write everything down, separate what is important from what is merely urgent, pick the three tasks that matter most today, and give each one a block of time before you touch the rest. The Eisenhower matrix, "eat the frog" and a quick impact-vs-effort check are three ways to do the sorting. Below is how each works, where they come from, and a worked example that turns a messy list of 15 tasks into a Top 3 and a real schedule.

Why does prioritizing feel so hard?

Prioritizing feels hard because the most important tasks are rarely the loudest ones. A message with a red badge, a colleague at your desk, a bill due tomorrow: these ask for attention right now. The proposal that will matter for the next six months does not. So the day fills with whatever shouts, and the important work slides to "tomorrow."

A second problem is that we misjudge how long things take. Research on the planning fallacy shows people predict that tasks will take less time than they do, even when they remember similar tasks running long. A list of ten "quick" things is often two days of work. Prioritizing is partly choosing what matters and partly admitting how little fits.

What is the Eisenhower matrix?

The Eisenhower matrix is a two-by-two grid that sorts tasks by two questions: is it urgent, and is it important? Each task lands in one of four boxes, and each box has a default action.

UrgentNot urgent
ImportantDo: deadlines today, real emergenciesSchedule: the work that moves things forward; block time for it
Not importantDelegate or batch: many messages, some requests, small adminDrop: busywork, low-value scrolling, "nice to have"

The box that matters most is the top right: important but not urgent. Planning, learning, the big project, health, relationships. Nothing forces you to do these today, which is exactly why they need a time block.

Did Eisenhower actually say it?

The matrix is named after Dwight D. Eisenhower, but the history is less tidy than most articles suggest. According to Quote Investigator, the earliest known version is from Eisenhower's August 19, 1954 address to the World Council of Churches in Evanston, Illinois. He did not present the idea as his own: he credited an unnamed "former college president" with saying, "I have two kinds of problems, the urgent and the important." The often-quoted line "What is important is seldom urgent and what is urgent is seldom important" seems to be a later paraphrase. And there is no clear evidence that Eisenhower used a four-box grid himself; the matrix was built and popularized by time-management writers afterward. The idea is still useful. It just isn't a presidential decision tool handed down from the Oval Office.

What is a Top 3 and why three?

A Top 3 is a short list of the three tasks that would make today worthwhile even if nothing else got done. Three is not magic; it's a practical limit. One large task and two smaller ones usually fit in a working day alongside meetings, messages and interruptions. Ten "top priorities" do not, so they stop meaning anything.

Fill the first slot with the task that matters most. Leave a slot empty if you have only two real priorities. The Top 3 section in the daily planner sits beside the schedule for exactly this reason: you pick three, then give them time.

What does "eat the frog" mean?

"Eat the frog" means doing your biggest, most important task first, before anything else. Brian Tracy built his book Eat That Frog! around the idea. He describes the frog as the most important task, the one you are most likely to procrastinate on, and advises starting it first thing in the morning and sticking with it until it's done.

In planner terms: your frog is slot 1 of your Top 3, and its time block goes at the start of your working day. If mornings are your worst hours, put it in your best hours instead. The principle is "before the day gets a vote," not a specific clock time.

How do you use impact vs. effort?

Impact vs. effort is a quick second filter for a long list: rate each task as high or low impact and high or low effort.

Low effortHigh effort
High impactQuick wins: do soon, often in one batchBig bets: your frog; block real time
Low impactFillers: gaps in the day, or neverTraps: question them hard

The matrix catches what the Eisenhower grid misses: two tasks can both be "important but not urgent" while one takes 20 minutes and the other takes two days. Quick wins can go in a single admin block; big bets need their own.

Worked example: from 15 messy tasks to a Top 3 and a schedule

Here is a real-looking Tuesday list for someone in an office job. It's in the order things came to mind, which is the order most lists are in.

  1. Finish Q1 budget proposal (due Friday)
  2. Reply to 23 unread emails
  3. Make slides for Thursday's client meeting
  4. Book dentist appointment
  5. Review Jordan's draft (he's waiting on it)
  6. Update the project tracker
  7. Pay electric bill (due tomorrow)
  8. Research new CRM tools
  9. Clean up desktop files
  10. Call landlord about the leaking tap
  11. Read industry newsletter
  12. Start planning team offsite (in two months)
  13. Order printer ink
  14. Answer Slack thread about logo colors
  15. Write a LinkedIn post

Step 1: Sort with the Eisenhower matrix

BoxTasks
Do (urgent + important)Pay electric bill (7), Review Jordan's draft (5)
Schedule (important, not urgent)Budget proposal (1), Client slides (3), Team offsite (12), Call landlord (10)
Delegate or batch (urgent, not important)Emails (2), Slack thread (14), Order ink (13), Project tracker (6), Dentist (4)
Drop or defer (neither)CRM research (8), Desktop files (9), Newsletter (11), LinkedIn post (15)

Two things already stand out. Only two items are truly urgent and important. And four items can leave the list today without anything bad happening.

Step 2: Check impact and effort inside the "Schedule" box

  • Budget proposal: high impact, high effort. A big bet, and the task most likely to be put off. This is the frog.
  • Client slides: high impact, medium effort, due in two days. Needs a block today or tomorrow.
  • Team offsite: high impact, but two months away. It belongs in the weekly review, not today.
  • Call landlord: important for you, low effort. A quick win; batch it.

Step 3: Pick the Top 3

  1. Budget proposal: write the full first draft (the frog)
  2. Client slides for Thursday
  3. Review Jordan's draft (someone else is blocked until it's done)

Notice what is not in the Top 3: the 23 emails. They will get time, just not the best time.

Step 4: Turn it into time blocks

TimeBlockFrom the list
9:00–10:45Budget proposal draft1
10:45–11:00Break
11:00–11:30Email and Slack, one batch2, 14
11:30–12:15Review Jordan's draft5
12:15–1:00Lunch
1:00–2:30Client slides3
2:30–3:00Admin batch: bill, dentist, ink, landlord7, 4, 13, 10
3:00–4:30Open: overflow, meetings, the unexpected
4:30–5:00Update tracker, plan tomorrow6

Eleven of the 15 tasks have a home. Four (CRM research, desktop files, newsletter, LinkedIn post) moved off today: the LinkedIn post to Friday's to-do list, the rest to a "someday" note. The 90 minutes from 3:00 to 4:30 are deliberately empty. If the budget draft runs long, which the planning fallacy says it might, this is where it goes.

How do you prioritize in the planner?

  1. Brain dump into the to-do list. Type each task and press Enter. Don't sort yet.
  2. Fill the Top 3. Frog first.
  3. Drag to add blocks for the Top 3 on the schedule: press at the start time, drag to the end time, name it. Use one color for Top 3 blocks so you can see them at a glance.
  4. Add one admin block for the quick wins and messages.
  5. Leave a gap for the unexpected, then tick tasks off the to-do list as you go.

Our to-do list page has more on keeping a list that doesn't grow forever, and the time blocking guide covers how long to make each kind of block.

Which prioritization method should you use?

If your problem is…Try
Urgent things crowd out important onesEisenhower matrix
Too many "priorities"Top 3
You keep putting off the one big taskEat the frog
A long list of important tasks of very different sizesImpact vs. effort

Most people end up using a mix: the matrix to clear the list, impact vs. effort to size what's left, and the Top 3 with a frog first to shape the day. Five minutes of sorting each morning is enough. Try it now with your own list in the free daily planner.

Frequently asked

What is the best way to prioritize tasks?

Write everything down, then sort it with one simple question: what would make today a good day if it were the only thing finished? Use the Eisenhower matrix to separate urgent from important, pick a Top 3, and give those three time blocks. The method matters less than doing the sorting before you start working.

What are the four quadrants of the Eisenhower matrix?

Urgent and important (do it now), important but not urgent (schedule it), urgent but not important (delegate it or keep it short), and neither urgent nor important (drop it). Most meaningful work lives in the second quadrant, which is why it needs time blocked on your calendar.

Did Eisenhower really invent the Eisenhower matrix?

Not as far as anyone can show. The matrix is named after him because of a 1954 speech in which he quoted an unnamed former college president about having two kinds of problems, the urgent and the important. The four-box grid itself was developed and popularized later by time-management writers.

What does eat the frog mean?

It is the idea, popularized by Brian Tracy in his book Eat That Frog!, that you should do your biggest, most important task first, ideally first thing in the morning, before smaller tasks take over the day. The frog is the task you are most likely to put off.

How many priorities should I have in a day?

Three is a good ceiling. One big task and two smaller ones fit in most days with room left for meetings, messages and the unexpected. If everything on your list is a priority, nothing is, so move the rest to the to-do list or to another day.

How do I prioritize when everything is urgent?

Check who set each deadline and what really happens if it slips by a day. Many 'urgent' items are only urgent for someone else, or can be handled in a short batch. Protect one block for the most important task, then handle the urgent items in a single batch rather than one by one.